Content
Summary
In liquid-liquid extractions, the position of aqueous and organic layers in a separatory funnel is determined by their relative densities. Non-halogenated organic solvents are typically less dense than water and form the upper layer, while halogenated solvents are denser and form the lower layer.
Intuition
When you mix two immiscible liquids in a separatory funnel, gravity sorts them by density, much like oil and water in a salad dressing. The lighter liquid floats on top of the heavier one. In the lab, this means you must know which solvent you are using to identify which layer is which. Most common organic solvents that do not contain halogens (like ether or hexanes) are lighter than water, so they sit on top. However, if you use a halogenated solvent like dichloromethane, it is heavier than water and will sink to the bottom. This distinction is critical because it dictates which layer you keep and which you discard during the extraction process.
Derivation
- Identify the two immiscible phases: aqueous and organic.
- Compare the density of the organic solvent to the density of the aqueous solution.
- Note that dilute aqueous solutions have a density of approximately 1 g/mL, similar to pure water (0.998 g/mL).
- If the organic solvent density is less than 1 g/mL (non-halogenated), it forms the upper layer.
- If the organic solvent density is greater than 1 g/mL (halogenated), it forms the lower layer.
Worked example
You are performing an extraction using dichloromethane (density 1.33 g/mL) and a dilute aqueous solution. Which layer is the organic layer?
- Identify the density of the organic solvent: dichloromethane has a density of 1.33 g/mL.
- Identify the density of the aqueous layer: a dilute aqueous solution has a density of approximately 1 g/mL.
- Compare densities: 1.33 g/mL is greater than 1 g/mL.
- Apply the principle: The denser liquid sinks to the bottom.
- Conclusion: The dichloromethane layer is the bottom layer.
Answer The organic layer (dichloromethane) is the bottom layer.
Common mistakes
- Assuming all organic solvents float on water; halogenated solvents are a notable exception and sink.
- Assuming the density of a dilute aqueous solution differs significantly from pure water; it is only slightly greater.